I had never heard this song until I got into the cover version from Joss Stone. Actually she switched up the gender and changed it to “Fell in Love With a Boy”. I’m a big fan of Joss Stone. She’s got an old-soul, rhythm voice that’s just amazing for someone so young. (Damn, whippersnapper!) She gives this a funk-tastic, sexy vibe. I love how the song opens with the scratch of an old 45 single. The great drumbeat is provided by producer and The Roots drummer Questlove.
The original version -“Fell in Love With a Girl” – was written and performed by The White Stripes. It’s a seriously fast-paced track that goes by in under 2 minutes. That’s practically unheard of these days. Hearing this original version is jarring compared to the smooth soul of Ms. Stone. This is very hard rock, loud, punk like. And just like Joss’s cover has an old throwback style to it, the White Stripes version also feels retro. Can’t say it’s something I would put on repeat, though, but the Lego video is pretty cool.
I found an acoustic version from the White Stripes as well. I’m kind of a sucker for stripped down, acoustic stuff and I could get into this more than the fully produced punk one. It’s making me wonder what it would sound like if Joss and the Stripes did a collaborative version. Could be amazing; could be a mild train wreck.
I also found something by The New Royales. It’s definitely more in line with the White Stripes feel. It adds a pulsing electronic sound that can get annoying, and possibly seizure inducing. It’s a good cover though. Pretty well-done.
The strangest cover I discovered is probably the most unexpected. It’s done as a “Lullaby Rendition” (?!?) and it’s just too freakin’ cute. I love this thing.